88 Comments
User's avatar
CJ's avatar

Library and History sub. At $250 annually, I would add this subscription.

1. Orthodoxy - G. K. Chesterton

2. Mere Christianity - C. S. Lewis

3. Summa Theologica - St. Thomas Aquinas

Most of Lewis’s works are fairly short, so I don’t know how feasible it would be to include 2-3 in one volume, or if that would be in line with the Castalia ethic, but it’s an idea to get more material to the subscribers per year.

I’m also with keruru. If Castalia could get the rights to the Space Trilogy, I would buy that in a heartbeat.

Expand full comment
Mitch Elston's avatar

Mere Christianity would be amazing but considering Lewis’ succinct writing within his apologetic works I would think half or more could be bound into one book.

Expand full comment
keruru's avatar

1. Confessions of St Augustine.

2. The imitation of Christ Thomas a Kempis.

3. 200 years... Alexandr Solzintsyn

Expand full comment
Anthony Voci's avatar

200 Years Together, Russia and the Jews is an excellent choice - the 1st Ed that WAS BANNED in the West and not printed in English!

Expand full comment
Jim's avatar

Here's a few quotes from 200 Years Together:

https://files.catbox.moe/pti3tl.jpg

https://files.catbox.moe/khk98o.jpg

Btw, also add:

On the Consolation of Philosophy - Boethius

Expand full comment
Big Chad Mungus's avatar

City of God and Summa Theologica are two of the most sought after leather volumes. Pilgrims Progress is printed in leather editions in high volume but is an obvious pick.

Expand full comment
Colonel Troll's avatar

1. A curated collection of creeds & confessions: Apostles Creed, Nicene, etc., Heidelberg confession, Westminster confession, etc.

2. Lives of the Apostles- where did they go, what did they do, when/how did the die (assuming someone has written that); James in Spain for example

Expand full comment
John Samson's avatar

1. Paradise Lost

2. St. John of the Cross, Ascent of Mount Carmel, with any combination of Dark Night of the Soul, Living Flame of Love, Spiritual Canticle (they’re short).

3. Tertullian, especially against heretics and unbelievers.

I’d pay a premium for a limited subscription complete Summa in however many volumes the process takes. A Christian subscription could even include historically significant ancillary works. Someone mentioned Philo. With extended options like a good Pseudo-Dionysius or Origen, or even Plotinus and Proclus, the denominational friction can be avoided in perpetuity.

Expand full comment
keruru's avatar

I would love the Summa by Aquinas. I once had a complete set of Calvin (lost it in a move, to my regret, but his Institutes are the equal.

Expand full comment
AnotherAnon's avatar

I would love to pay for a Christian subscription. However, I'm a Catholic. Pilgrim's Progress, no matter how beautifully illustrated, is a hard pass as an anti-Catholic work. If I'm mostly supporting the reprinting of people who, at very best don't understand my faith, then that's not a good use of money.

I'll watch for what you've got for individual titles as they come out. Pre-Luther works will probably be the most unifying. Dante is of great interest, Chesterton is now in the public domain, is as Hilliare Belloc.

Expand full comment
The Rogue Roman's avatar

This is why a Christian Castalia subscription should limit itself to the Church Fathers and other First Millennium writers.

Catholics will oppose Bunyan just as strongly as Protestants will support him.

Expand full comment
Pelayo Asturias's avatar

Aquila’s Summa

Early Church Fathers - selected works

Expand full comment
Ed's avatar

1. City of God by St. Augustine.

2. Orthodox by Chesterton.

3. Summa Theologica by Aquinas.

Expand full comment
Goldfishbutton's avatar

As a catholic mentioned elsewhere, I would not be interested in most protestant works since I am Orthodox. So a subscription may not suit my needs best, but perhaps for others it would.

On Marriage and Family, by St John Chrysostom would be one I'd love to buy for keeps. Additional pre-schism works would be appreciated as well.

Expand full comment
Kiko's avatar

There are so many great works of the pre-schism saints, no need to go beyond for the initial subscription.

Expand full comment
The Rogue Roman's avatar

The Apologies of St. Justin Martyr.

Any other early church fathers.

I also think it would be best to stick with authors from before the Reformation and the Great Schism.

Expand full comment
Blue Eyes Huwhyte Dragon's avatar

1. War, Progress, and the End of History: Three Conversations, Including a Short Story of the Anti-Christ by Vladimir Soloviev

2. The Everlasting Man by G. K. Chesterton

3. Nihilism: The Root of the Revolution of the Modern Age by Fr. Seraphim Rose

4. The Spiritual Combat by Dom Lorenzo Scupoli

Expand full comment
Your mom's avatar

I 2nd The Spiritual Combat. Written by a catholic but was also widely popular in the East, enough so that additions were made by an Orthodox fellow. The version with the Ortho additions would be my pick, also it would have more braod appeal.

Expand full comment
Jason Raines's avatar

Bede the Venerable’s Ecclesiastical History of the English People

Expand full comment
Anthony Voci's avatar

Martin Luther, The Jews and Their Lies.

Expand full comment
George's avatar

I am already working on attractive hardcover collections of St. Thomas Aquinas and St. Augustine, so

1) Golden Legend, Jacobus de Voragine

2) Pastoral Rule, St. Gregory the Great

3) Sayings of the Desert Fathers

Expand full comment
Aidan Scott's avatar

1) The City of God by Augustine of Hippo

2) Summa Theologica by Thomas Aquinas (Prima Pars)

3) End of the Timeless God by R.T. Mullins

Expand full comment
Jose Miguel's avatar

1 The Fount of Knowledge: The Philosophical Chapters, On Heresies and On the Orthodox Faith - St. John Damascene. First Christian Summa written, is pre-Schism, and is one of the works that Aquinas cites in his Summa

2 The Ladder of Divine Ascent - St John Climacus. Pre-Schism, practical teaching on the Christian Life. Also happens to be the first book printed in the Americas in the early 16th century.

3 Sayings of the Desert Fathers - Desert Fathers.

Expand full comment